Each year a ceremony involving the slaughter of a huge number of chickens creates a furor when the ritual’s site is left strewn with feces, feathers and other debris.
The organizers of the kapparot ritual, in which a live chicken is held above a person’s head and moved in a circle three times before it is slaughtered, say they do their best to avoid sanitation and health problems.
And each year the Rockland Department of Health finds fault with their work.
There have been problems for years, including chickens running loose a few years back, although that may have happened with another organizer.
In 2007, the sanitation problems brought fines of $3,000 after Rockland mistakenly allowed Moshe Lefkowitz to use the site of the old Rockland Drive-in on Route 59 in Monsey, thinking the county owned the property. That year, the ritual, in the days before Yom Kippur, involved 11,000 chickens.
In February of this year, Lefkowitz wrote a letter, which was published on our editorial page, in which he issued a qualified apology for the problems with the 2007 ritual, although he deflected blame for the cleanliness issues. “The county government officials,” his letter read, “were fair in fining me. I respect them for their professionalism and what they did was correct. I am sad that anyone can be mistaken about that.”
Since then, he’s paid less than half of the $3,000 fine and this past October, at a different site, the ritual involved as many as 13,000 chickens with much the same result. This time blood was also allowed to drain into a catch basin.
Although the violations this year could carry fines of up to $10,000, a lesser amount has been proposed by a Board of Health hearing officer. Only the lack of a quorum prevented the board from passing on the fines this week.
This time, Lefkowitz says he doesn’t believe he should be fined at all. That after an inspector told the board that Lefkowitz and his son were warned repeatedly about the ongoing sanitary problems. Kevin Mackey told the board the situation got worse rather than better as the week progressed.
Lefkowitz, in fact, said he was proud of the job he did this year. “This year was much better,” he said.
A lawyer for the school that hosted this year’s ritual didn’t sound like the chickens will be welcomed back, which means Lefkowitz will likely need a new site for 2009.
He also need a new plan. It’s way past time to scale back the size of the ritual, if only for a year or two, until they figure out how to hold it without compromising the public health.
Before Lefkowitz gets a break on his 2008 fines, he should also be required to pay the balance of the fines outstanding from 2007.
Rockland has been more than willing to work with Lefkowitz, but now he had to hold up his end and make things right.